Homemade Birthday and Special Occasion Dog Cakes

Hey there, pawty animals! Homemade cakes for dogs are the next tasty treat on the pet chef menu. As the next instalment in our current FAQs, Tips, and Troubleshooting mini-series topic all about treats, it’s time to celebrate with cake. At our place, dog-friendly cake is usually a special occurrence for homemade dog birthday cakes, but any excuse to party will do! Here’s our introduction to making homemade dog-friendly cakes, pupcakes, and meatball treats for dog birthdays, special occasions, or just because.

My First Homemade Pet Treats

The first homemade pet “treat” that I can recall making was not for a dog, but for a cat. I adopted scrawny little rescue kitty Tiger sixteen years ago (Tiger passed away earlier this year). We didn’t know his real birthday, but I started making him a little birthday cat cake every year on his vet nominated birthday. Tiger was always very picky about what he would and wouldn’t eat, so every year we would celebrate with dinner in the form of his favourite wet food in a round cake-ish shape decorated with cat biscuits and treats.

After we blended furfamilies, the tradition expanded to include Oli. Oli’s early homemade dog birthday cakes were casserole dish dinners with a candle. Nothing flashy, but doggone delish and he knew it was something special. Momma’s treat making skills have come along way since then. He has trained me well! Although I enjoy making my crazy cakes and the excitement our boys get from cake time, it’s important to note that special celebrations don’t require anything fancy. Just lots of love and whatever makes you and your pet happiest.

Conventional Homemade Cakes and Pupcakes for Dogs

The process of preparing and baking a conventional dog-friendly cake is no different than baking for humans. Unless you’re using stock, meat, or fish, the batter and resulting cake will be very similar to a no-sugar low-fat human muffin. With the right flavour combination, you might even decide to share!

Dog-Friendly Cake Ingredients

When baking conventional homemade cakes for dogs (or cupcakes, muffins, and pupcake treats), flour will likely be one of the ingredients. Instead of typical human white cake flour or all-purpose flour, wholemeal flour can be used as a healthier upgrade for dogs without grain or gluten sensitivities. Alternatively, you can opt for a gluten-free flour. Ingredients like dog-friendly fruits and vegetables can be used to help bulk things up and give the cake additional size without being a total overload carbs.

Most conventional cakes and pupcakes use some sort of leaveners to give them rise. These may include eggs, self-raising flour, baking powder, baking soda, etc. Baking with yeast is not recommended for dogs.

Ingredients such as eggs, chia seed, flax, and many of the flavoursome add-ins below act as binders. Binders are what hold baked goods together and assist with texture, and are extra important when using gluten-free flours.

To give the cake a tempting scent and flavour, the recipe could include compatible combinations of stock, chopped cooked meat, chopped cooked or tinned fish, dog safe herbs and spices, peanut butter, carob, yogurt, cheese, coconut milk, dog-friendly fruits and vegetables, and more. These make the cakes yummy, of course, but can be used to make a somewhat healthier cake instead of just a pretty but low-value (especially for dogs) carb-loaded cake.

See our post on choosing and using ingredients for homemade dog treats for more info and ideas. Keen to start baking? You can fast forward to our collection of dog cakes and pupcakes for recipes and more. Read on for more tasty info on homemade cakes for dogs.

Homemade Meatloaf Cakes and Meatball Treats for Dogs

Another tasty option for homemade cakes for dogs is to use meat baked in cake shape. Meatloaf style dog cake can be prepared using a dog-friendly recipe, or you can easily adapt your favourite meatloaf or meatball recipe to a dog-friendly version. A flexible variation for special diets is to simple shape meat into a cake look-alike. Check out our cake-less dog birthday steak cake for an example.

Ingredients for Meatloaf Dog Cakes

Lean ground meat or fish is all that is required for a very basic baked cake, although you may want to use a small casserole dish instead of a cake pan. Including some binders and oats (and/or a suitable flour) can help substantially with moisture, texture, and holding shape once baked. Your imagination is the limit in creating a special cake with flavours and ingredients that your individual dog loves. Dog-friendly shredded vegetables and/or herbs and spices work well with meats and fish for additional texture, variety, scent, and flavour.

Baking Meatloaf Cakes for Dogs

Dense meat and fish cakes can be more difficult to remove from pans than conventional cakes. Choose your baking pan or dish with care and ensure it is well-prepped before use. I like using mini-spring form pans (affiliate link). They’re a great size for making a small cake. The springform sides help with removing the meatloaf cakes intact, but you still need to loosen and lift with care.

Swapping Cakes for Easy Meatball Treats

If you want bite-sized snacks, meatballs are a good alternative to mini-muffins and fiddly tiny tins. Dog-friendly meatballs also make great treats in their own right. They’re easy to make, bake, store, freeze, and use in small quantities, either as treats or as special meal toppers.

Explore our collection of dog cakes and pupcakes or meatloaf and meatball dog treats for recipes, ideas, and more.

Dog-Friendly Cake Frosting and Decorations

Homemade Frosting and Icing for Dog Cakes

Dog cakes and pupcakes can be frosted for extra special occasions. Use a dog-friendly frosting without all the sugar and fat of human icings. For savoury meat and fish cakes, my current go-to dog-friendly frosting is mashed potato. It’s easy to work with, looks good, and our dogs can have a little in moderation every now and then no worries.

Some icing flavours, like yogurt, pureed pumpkin, and applesauce, can work for either meat and fish cakes or conventional cakes. You can also firm them up with some flour (coconut flour works well – it’s very absorbent so only a small amount is needed) for a better layering and decorating texture. Depending on the cake flavours, peanut butter, cream cheese, or unsweetened whipped cream can work too.

If preparing things in advance, don’t ice your cake or pupcakes until shortly before you’re ready to serve. They be easier to handle, will store better unfrosted, and look better for the party. Freezing leftover cake for a future special snacks is a-ok though. See storage tips below.

Sprinkles, Decorations, and Cake Toppers

Want sprinkles on that? Potential dog-friendly sprinkles include small/ground dog-friendly nuts and seeds, grated cheese, crumbled cooked bacon, dog jerky, or even ready-made treats/kibble. Feeling crazy? Tinted panko, coconut, or oats can be used as a dog-friendly rainbow sprinkle substitute. See some of our dog birthday cakes for ideas. I like having fun dressing up our homemade cake for dogs, especially for big occasions like their birthdays.

Other dog-friendly cake decorations include small (or small pieces of) fruits, berries, vegetables, or dog treats. Treats can be used to make special edible cake toppers that look cute and your dog can enjoy instead of icky old candles. Can’t eat those! Normal candles should only be used with great care around pets. Lit candles are hazardous around excited pets. Some pets also find them very scary.

See our collection of homemade dog birthday cakes for recipes, decorating ideas, and more.

Storing Homemade Dog Cakes and Pupcakes

Storing Conventional Dog-Friendly Cakes and Pupcakes

Conventional baked cakes and pupcakes are very similar to human muffins, and should be stored similarly for short term consumption. Shelf life will depend on individual ingredients and moisture content, but is very limited, unless frozen.

Many stable baked goods can be briefly stored in a suitable container (or wrapped) at room temperature, kept a little longer in the fridge, or frozen longer term. Allow them to cool thoroughly prior to container storage. Putting warm cakes into a contain will trap residual steam and/or moisture, which can accelerate spoilage. Once cool, transfer the treats to a suitable container.

If your cake or pupcakes contain ingredients like meat, fish, or are otherwise unsuitable for ambient storage, handle with extra care. They should be refrigerated short term or frozen for longer storage.

Storing Meatloaf Dog Cakes and Meatball Treats

Meatballs and meatloaf-style cakes are also no different than their human equivalents in terms of storage. They require refrigeration for the short term and freezing for extended storage. Shelf life is very limited, unless frozen. Pampered pups might like their meaty treats warmed before serving to enhance the scent and flavour. My boys will happily munch them cool (or even frozen), but warm and stinking is extra special. Doggone delish!

Keen to Try a Few Treats?

Ready to get cooking? We have all sorts of treat related posts here on the blog. You can sniff around our DIY dog recipes, use our categories and tags to navigate, or use the internal search function to look for specific types or treats or treat ingredients. You can also hop over to our DIY Dog Treat Recipes board on Pinterest for ideas from here and all around the web. We’ve also started a Pet Chef Help board on Pinterest with handy links on things like ingredients, substitutions, conversions, tinting, and more. Check out the full mini-series topic for an introduction to the main categories of different homemade dog treats we make and share here on the blog:

Hungry for more tasty treats? There are all sorts of homemade dog treat ideas in our blog archives. You can also use the category and tag labels to find other recipes that might be of interest or use our internal search tools to find something specific. Remember, treats (bought or homemade) are for spoiling your pup in moderation. We share ideas from treats that we’ve made ourselves for our pets, but different animals have different preferences (likes/dislikes), just like people. Some pets may have special dietary requirements and/or food allergies/intolerances. If you are ever in doubt or have questions about what’s suitable for your pet, have a chat with your trusted vet.