DIY Stacked Star Christmas Tree Dog Treats

Homemade stacked star Christmas tree dog treats

Oh yes I did… Hehe! These little stacked star Christmas tree dog treat towers are assembled with carob “glue” and decorated with carob and yogurt. They are a very cute little gift to make for your favourite furfriends this holiday season. Here’s how to make your own!

Not Quite a Recipe...

Green Tree Dough Fail

I experimented with a kiwifruit dough to see if I could get a natural green without turning to artificial colouring or green veggies. Veggies and carob? Bleuch! Although I’m sure the dogs would still love it! I didn’t want to go crazy with the kiwi, so used it along in combination with banana and other add-ins. The resulting dough was a lovely minty green but baked up to a muddier greenish brown, which I should have expected. Fail! Oh well, live and learn! The dogs loved it all the same. It smelled pretty great to the humans, too.

Baking green star-shaped dog treat with kiwifruit

Choosing a Base Dough Recipe

Anything goes! These trees looked beautiful in beige. I think they probably looked better than if I had been more successful with my greens, to be honest. I think these would also be fabulously festive with a doggy gingerbread as well.

The stars for the tree can be made using any roll-and-cut dog treat dough. If you’re planning to tint, the lighter the dough, the easier it will be to tint true colours. You can read more about tinting treats in our post on using natural food colourings for dog treats.

Homemade stacked star Christmas tree dog treats with yogurt and carob

Making the Stacked Star Christmas Tree Dog Treats

Treat Making Tools

In addition to the usual baking supplies and materials, you will need a set of star-shaped cookie cutters or other graduated cutter, like snowflakes or even ordinary circles. If you’re feeling extra fancy, there are even special Christmas tree stack cookie cutter sets! A couple of small squeeze bottles or similar are very handy for working with your melted carob and yogurt as well.

🥄 Treat Decorating Ingredients:

  • Roll-and-cut dog treat dough made with your chosen recipe (see above)
  • Dog-friendly carob drops/melts and/or yogurt drops/melts
  • Peanut butter and/or coconut oil

Carob and yogurt drops are often sweetened, whether you are buying them from the human baking good section or specially marketed dog treats. Many are a combination of sugars and oils with carob powder, some are unsweetened carob and oil mixtures. There’s nothing wrong with an occasional special treat, but always read your ingredients to know what you’re buying and eating/sharing. Also, take care when shopping to avoid artificial sweeteners in ingredients peanut butter when used for your dogs. Xylitol (E967) is particularly dangerous for dogs.

🥄 Making the Treats:

  • Preheat the oven and gather your baking supplies and equipment.
  • Mix the dough according to your chosen recipe.
  • Roll and cut into star shapes, making sure that you have the incremental sizes for stacking
  • Bake according to your chosen recipe.
  • Ensure your treats are fully cooled before beginning to assemble your towers.
  • Optional: Pre-chill your prepped stars. This is optional, but will accelerate the setting of your “glue” and ornaments to reduce the risk of running.
Making stacked star Christmas tree dog treats with yogurt and carob

🥄 Assembling the Treat Christmas Tree Towers:

Prepping the carob and yogurt:

  • Combine carob drops/melts with peanut butter. Melt and pour into your squeeze bottle and place in a hot water bath to keep liquid while you work (optional, but lets you work slower if needed). Carob drops can be tricky to melt compared to chocolate, as carob is usually drier/lower fat. Combining the carob with the peanut butter and gently melting them together can help. Individual carob and peanut butters may vary, but in my experiences to date equal roughly equal measures set to a firm fudgey solid texture. You can use a little less if you want a harder set or swap in a little coconut oil if you need a runnier liquid.
  • Melt yogurt drops/melts, pour into your squeeze bottle, and place in a hot water bath to keep liquid while you work (optional, but lets you work slower if needed). Unlike carob, yogurt drops/melts are generally pretty free melting, but you can add a little coconut oil if needed for melting or to thin to a runnier liquid. Just a little, else your liquid may become too runny for decorating and/or might not set firmly.

Assembling and decorating the treats:

  • Working from bottom to top, use your melted carob or yogurt as glue between your star layers. Not too much – you want to hold the trees in shape, but will also want to pop them apart for smaller treat eating portions later. Rotate the stars into an offset position as you stack.
  • Decorate with additional carob and yogurt.
  • Decorate any extra stars and shapes as individual separate treats, if you wish.
  • Allow to set thoroughly and enjoy!
Homemade star and Christmas tree dog treats with yogurt and carob

Labelling and Gifting

If you are prepping your holiday gifts, we have lots of free printable tags and labels in our archives. To fancy things up even further, check out Kidecals, which is where we got the pawesome wash-and-wear labels pictured above. If you’d like to try Kidecals for yourself, you can use coupon code summersavings (don’t be too jealous, but it’s summertime down here) at check out to save a tidy 15% on your purchase. Kidecals are great for labelling school, sports, club, and travel gear, but don’t let that stop you from using them for other needs, like we did with our emergency contact tags. Very handy.

Disclosure: Discounted Kidecals products were provided for my use on a no-obligation basis. Opinions provided are my own and are an honest representation of my user experience.

🦴 Hungry for more tasty treats? There are all sorts of different DIY dog treats here on the blog. Woofs! Remember, treats (bought or homemade) are for spoiling your pup in moderation. We share ideas here from treats that we make ourselves for our pets, but different animals will have different preferences (likes or dislikes) and dietary needs. Some pets may have special dietary requirements and/or food allergies or intolerances. If you are ever in doubt or have questions about what’s suitable for your pet, have a chat with your trusted vet.

DIY stacked star Christmas tree dog treats

You Might Also Enjoy: